Internet and e-mail policy and practice
including Notes on Internet E-mail


2011
Months
Dec

Click the comments link on any story to see comments or add your own.


Subscribe to this blog


RSS feed


Home :: Email

07 Dec 2011

More on Greylisting still works Email

Last month I blogged about greylisting, a well-known anti-spam technique for rejecting spam sent by botnets. When a mail server receives a an attempt to deliver mail from an IP address that's never sent mail before, it rejects the message with a "soft fail" error which tells the sender to try again later. Real mail senders always retry, badly written spamware often doesn't. I found that even though everyone knows about greylisting, about 2/3 of IPs don't successfully retry.

Another theory about greylisting is that if you defer mail from a new IP, by the time the sender retries, if it's sending spam it'll have hit spamtraps and been added to blacklists. I recently realized that I have enough log data to check that theory, so I collected some statistics for the past week, which is as long as I keep logs about mail connections from blacklisted hosts. The IPs I greylisted broke down like this:

 CountPercent
No retry3,80335.8%
Retry too soon3,34531.5%
One retry1,18311.1%
More than one message1,63515.4%
Blacklisted5615.3%
Retried, blacklisted later890.8%
Total10,616100.0%

No retry and Retry too soon are senders that greylisting kept from sending anything, again, about 2/3 of mail. (My greylister requires that the sender wait at least a minute, since some spamware sends several messages a few seconds apart.)

The next two are senders that retried successfully and sent one message, or more than one message. (If a sender retries too soon, then retries again after more than a minute, it's counted in one of those two categories.) Blacklisted means that when the IP retried, the IP was on one of the a blacklists I use, in nearly all cases Spamhaus Zen. The last line is IPs that retried successfully, but were blacklisted when they tried to send other messages later.

The 5.3% for Blacklisted probably overstates how much mail was caught by waiting to see if an IP was blacklisted. My logs don't say whether the delivery attempt that was blacklisted was trying to deliver a message with the same To and From addresses, in which case it would have been delivered, or a different message, in which case it would just have been greylisted again. Spot checking shows IPs that were greylisted repeatedly, before appearing in a blacklist, which suggests that they were sending different messages.

Also, for the few IPs that were blacklisted later, they were generally blacklisted much later, hours or days later, far longer than any reasonable greylisting strategy would force mail to wait.

So greylisting still works, but it's almost entirely because spamware doesn't retry, not because it gets blacklisted.


posted at: 23:13 :: permanent link to this entry :: 0 comments
Stable link is https://jl.ly/Email/grey11a.html

Topics


My other sites

Who is this guy?

Airline ticket info

Taughannock Networks

Other blogs

CAUCE
Dave Piscitello on Ransomware
96 days ago

A keen grasp of the obvious
My high security debit card
642 days ago

Related sites

Coalition Against Unsolicited Commercial E-mail

Network Abuse Clearinghouse



© 2005-2020 John R. Levine.
CAN SPAM address harvesting notice: the operator of this website will not give, sell, or otherwise transfer addresses maintained by this website to any other party for the purposes of initiating, or enabling others to initiate, electronic mail messages.