Click the comments link on any
story to see comments or add your own.
Subscribe to this blog
Home :: Email
28 May 2019
The IETF's DMARC working group
is thinking about a maintenance update to the DMARC spec, fixing bits that are unclear and
perhaps changing it where what mail servers do doesn't exactly agree with what it says.
Someone noted that a lot of mailers claim to have ``deployed DMARC'', and it's not at
at all clear what that really means.
See more ...
Stable link is https://jl.ly/Email/dmarcwhat.html
03 May 2018
Recently I've been working on EAI mail, looking at what software is
available (Gmail and Outlook/Hotmail both handle it now) and what
work remains to be done.
A surprisingly tricky part is assigning EAI addresses to users.
In traditional ASCII mail, the local part of the address, what
goes before the @ sign, can be any printable ASCII characters.
Although an address like %i()/;~email@example.com is valid, and
mail systems will handle it, users don't want addresses like
A good address is one that is easy to remember, easy to tell someone over the phone,
and easy to type.
Mail systems all give senders some help
when interpreting addresses. If an address is Bob@example,
they'll accept bob@ or BOB@. If the address is joe.smith@,
they'll accept Joe.Smith@ and often variations in punctuation
like joesmith@ without the dots.
The flip side of this is that you don't assign different addresses
that are too similar. While it is techincally possible that BOB@
and bob@ could deliver to different mailboxes, nobody does that.
Similarly, nobody makes joesmith@ and joe.smith@ different.
(They may not both work, but if they do, they're the same mailbox.)
The domain (the part of the address after the @ sign) has to follow the
DNS rules, which don't allow any fuzzy matching other than ASCII upper
and lower case.
How does all this extend into EAI mail?
See more ...
Stable link is https://jl.ly/Email/eaiaddr.html
21 Apr 2017
Classified ad site craigslist is famously protective of its contents.
While they are happy for search engines like Google to index the
listings, they really, really do not like third parties to scrape
and republish their content in other forms.
In 2013 craigslist sued a company called 3taps which had created
an API for craigslist data. They also sued real estate site Padmapper, which
showed craigslist and other apartment listings on a map, something
craigslist didn't do at the time.
3taps eventually gave up and in 2015 paid craigslist $1 million and shut down.
Craigslist donated the money to the EFF which was a little odd since the EFF
had generally supported 3taps.
One of 3taps' other customers was another real estate site Radpad, which
kept showing craigslist listings after 3taps shut down.
See more ...
Stable link is https://jl.ly/Email/radpad.html
26 Jan 2017
In September I wrote about a proposal to allow one-click
unsubscriptions from mailing lists without user interaction.
After taking a rather tortuous path through the IETF, it's now been issued
as RFC 8058. The changes
since September are quite minor, mostly tightening up some details to prevent
various attacks from fake unsub requests.
Now that it's official, I expect email service providers will start implementing it,
and we'll have an arguably better alternative to mail feedback loops to tell
mailers when their mail is unwanted.
Stable link is https://jl.ly/Email/oneclickrfc.html
20 Dec 2016
I have groused at length
about the damage that anti-phishing technique DMARC does to e-mail discussion lists.
For at least two years list managers and list software developers have been trying to
figure out what to do about it.
The group that brought us DMARC is working on an un-DMARC-ing scheme
called ARC, which will likely help
somewhat, but ARC isn't ready yet, and due to ARC's complexity it's likely
that there will be many medium or small mail systems that enforce DMARC
and can't or won't use ARC.
The Internet Engineering Task Force, which writes technical standards for
the Internet, works primarily through discussion lists, and the pain from
DMARC has gotten to the point where we may do something about it.
So we've been doing some experiments.
See more ...
Stable link is https://jl.ly/Email/wrapme.html
My other sites
Who is this guy?
Airline ticket info
CSA recap: CAUCE discusses international email and security
56 days ago
A keen grasp of the obvious
My high security debit card
186 days ago
Coalition Against Unsolicited Commercial E-mail
Network Abuse Clearinghouse